Showing posts with label experience shift. Show all posts
Showing posts with label experience shift. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Beyond the Middle

Lately, I’ve been laughing. Sometimes a soft chuckle, other times a belly guffaw, and once a side-splitting, tear-jerking, silent seizing. The political satire sailing back and forth is hilarious.

Smiling over Maureen Dowd’s piece in the Sunday New York Times, however, my grin turned upside down. It occurred to me: no one who intends to vote for McCain or Palin will find this funny.

Dowd is one of many who are not only preaching to the choir but doing so in a way that reinforces the wall between parties with layers of scorn. We who read and laugh can’t possibly imagine that someone would actually buy what the other camp is selling! Mockery fosters hostility, intolerance, and elitism—all in fun. It isn’t possible to communicate with them, so why even try? Our opponents are just plain wrong.

Except that they aren’t. Any side is a side. Isn’t there a better way?
*
Tilting towards the political these last few weeks, it may seem that my blog is leaning far beyond its intended scope of our desires for food, sex, and spirit. However, what is at stake in this election, when it comes right down to it, is precisely our desire for spirit.

How so? As noted, a desire for spirit is a desire for a sense of vitality, direction, and belonging that gets people out of bed in the morning, willing to believe that life is worth living. It is a desire that finds its pleasure as we participate consciously in naming and bringing into being a world we love that loves us. It is a desire that makes its wisdom known in patterns of chronic frustration, depression, and despair.

People across the nation are feeling acutely a frustration with the current administration and its policies—a frustration that signals to us that we want more. We want new energy, a new direction, and a renewed sense of belonging to a country of which we are proud. We want change in which we can believe, and both parties are selling it to us.

However, if you take a look, you can see that the positions offered in response to this frustrated desire fan out along the mind over body spectrum we have identified in relation to our desires for food, sex, and spirit. At this end, one party is calling individuals to develop greater will power and self-restraint among individuals and corporations. At that end, one party is calling for more effective government regulation of and involvement in key industries and services.

The response to the recent collapse of Lehman Brothers investment bank is case in point. McCain attributes the crises to excessive greed, while Obama points to the absence of government regulation over the derivatives markets.

Both responses, however, reinforce the mind over body logic they share. Whether the mind in question is individual or collective, the dynamic is the same: we are led to believe that we will bring into being the world we want to see by exercising the power of mind to rule over the renegade bodies that are abusing our precious freedoms.

From this perspective, both visions of change are offering us more of the same. There are differences and those differences matter, but they do not matter enough to make a real difference.

We, as individuals and as a country, need our own version of what I have been describing in these posts as an “experience shift”: we must learn to discern the wisdom in our sensations of frustrated desire.
*
Simply promising more or less government is way too crude a tool to deal with the issues of our time. The messy negotiations conducted amidst tightly strung webs of conflicting commitments merit careful attention—but not just that. Change happens so quickly that we need to be able to recognize when and how government action is necessary, and when it isn’t. We need to cultivate a sensory awareness of how the movements we are making--as individuals, communities, corporations, and country—are making us. This is not just a question of accountability; it is rather a willingness to discern the impulses to move locked in patterns of chronic pain and frustration and see them as something other than either a matter of will power or government control.

When we examine the movements contributing to our current dissatisfaction, we find a common thread: inequality. The movements we make when we think and feel and act as if we were minds over bodies serve to concentrate power in the hands of those who reinforce this belief. Ironically, we place our faith in larger and larger institutions that promise to give us the economic, political, personal, or spiritual autonomy over our material circumstances that our mind over body training teaches us to want. Political parties included.

This inequality is soon structural. It is what we are creating—not as a result of excessive greed or lack of government oversight, but as a result of our willingness to create relationships with those who promise us the mind over body power we believe will grant us the sense of vitality, direction, and belonging we seek.

The crux of the matter is this: are we moving in ways that foster relationships in which all entities benefit? This is the question that a government by the people and for the people must answer. For if one party to an exchange has a much greater concentration of power, then that is where government is needed—to ensure a mutually enabling relationship.

Banks depend upon the solvency of individuals as much as individuals depend upon the solvency of banks. If the benefits accruing from a relationship are one-sided, then it is in everyone’s interest to provide a counterbalance—not regulation for the sake of regulation, but an articulated sense of the common good, the shared principles and rules that enable the play to continue.


This logic is what we have been working with of the past few months: In so far as we are intent on naming and bringing into being a world we love that loves us, we are obligated to let others live as the condition of our own freedom. This is something that we all must embrace—our ends both tempered and empowered by what we share. This country. This planet. This race. This tomato.


Next Week: Enabling Freedom

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

He Said, She Said

The political race is degenerating. It is increasingly a matter of he said, s/he said. Palin says she said no to the bridge to nowhere. Obama says she said yes. Biden says he is for change. McCain says he is not. The list goes on and on. Back and forth. A tennis match, but hardly as enjoyable. There is so much at stake. Whom do you believe?

I think again. For whom are we voting anyway? Or more to the point—for what? We are voting for the candidates, yes, but really, for the parties who have nominated them, fund them, back them, and cheer for them. These candidates are where they are, in the public eye and on the public stage, because two very large networks, with critical nodes throughout our country, have put them there.

Each candidate is merely the tip of an iceberg. The race is about which conglomeration of people—which cadre of experts and advisors, rising stars and time-tested sages—will have the edge in the ongoing scrum of political debates at all levels of government. We are voting for a team, or a horde, and the candidate who wins is the one who can best sell the dream—a victory vision of who we are, who we want to be, and what this party can help us be.

This is the issue, even more than the issues. We all know that when candidates get into office, they don’t always make good on their campaign promises. The reasons are many. Sometimes acts of nature or terrorism transform the terrain; sometimes the larger political machinery blocks attempts at change; sometimes advisors prevail in a different direction, and sometimes candidates tell the people what they want to hear, knowing everything will be different once they are in office. But we who listen and seek to discern hope that the candidates are making their promises with the intention of trying to carry them out. We trust them at least to try.

Which brings me back to the dream--and the bridge. It is what some Democrats still don’t seem to get. Simply opposing McCain or Palin’s claims won’t work to deflate the Republican fervor. The opposition only serves to strengthen the terms of their arguments. For example, opposing Palin’s claims about the bridge to nowhere simply strengthens the notion that what matters is reducing government, ending earmarks, and winning a reputation as a reformer.

The opposition to her position, in other words, reinforces the very standards of value that Republicans are selling. If you buy into the Democratic rebuttal of Palin, your opposition plays right into the Republican hand, for the Republican party has succeeded—despite the facts of history—to solidify an image of itself as promoting small, fiscally-responsible government. Resistance is futile.

It is a great irony: the Republicans in office, due to their failures and excesses, have stirred in us a deep desire for Republican values of restraint and conservatism. The Republicans in office have set up the Republican candidates perfectly to make the age-old criticisms of Democrats, however off base, as guaranteeing bigger government and higher taxes. The barbs stick.

I am not taking sides here. On the contrary. My point is to understand how arguments by both parties are reinforcing the ways of thinking that have failed to provide us with what we, as citizens, most want.

So what more is possible? We must displace the discussion by offering an alternative vision of the dream. We need to honor the failures and excesses of the current administration as what our movements towards small government and low taxes are themselves creating. We need to ask which party will give us the tools that we need, the new vision we need, to learn from the pain of our current situation how to move differently. We need an experience shift, so that we can find, trust, and move with the wisdom in our desire for more.

One way to begin is to note that the value we accord to small government and low taxes hinges on the idea of individual freedom and what it takes to sustain it. Yet the fact is, as Obama has stated, the kinds of individual freedoms we prize in the United States are given to us and enabled for us by a vast network of relationships. We are free because there are people in our lives who educate us, manufacture for us, protect us, heal us, and raise us. In this light, in order to ensure our freedom, we need a government then that will support individuals in creating the relationships they need to support them in unfolding what they have to give.

Such a government may or may not be big or small, in the war or out, drilling or not. It may or may not offer earmarks. But what that government will do is evaluate all such policies based on whether or not they support individuals in creating the relationships that will enable them to thrive. It will maximize the opportunities for individuals to participate consciously in the rhythms of their bodily becoming, naming and bringing into being a world they love that loves them.

In this light, what matters about Palin’s comments on the bridge is whether she is providing us with a criterion of governing that serves our vision of the democratic good. Simply abolishing earmarks is not enough. A government without them will not necessarily guarantee our freedoms. We need to know what will.

Next week: A harder case